Infinity Auto Insurance Review | Armstrong Insurance

Infinity Auto Insurance Company is a non-standard auto insurance provider that mainly writes policies through independent agencies and brokers. We would recommend drivers living in Arizona, California, Florida, or Texas, to look into Infinity if you have less than perfect driving history and are just looking to get the state minimum coverage while keeping annual insurance premium costs low. It has a unique design of policy features that allows consumers to take further control of their car insurance costs. However, we recommend that consumers compare quotes with other non-standard insurance providers before making a decision – Infinity seemed to be slightly pricier than other non-standard insurers for the few drivers we looked at. If you are not sure if you need a non-standard auto insurance policy - or high risk auto insurance. 

What we like best about Infinity:

  • Major player within the non-standard auto insurance market
  • Tiered Policy Coverage that gives drivers low-cost choices based on extent of coverage chosen
  • Cheap roadside service program available nationwide: Infinity DriverClub®

Considerations about Infinity:

  • Limited availability: as of 2015, it only writes new business in four states
  • Higher than average amount of complaints on claim payouts

Infinity vs. other non-standard car insurer: However, when compared with other non-standard car insurance providers, in our case Western General and Mercury, Infinity appears to be more costly than both for drivers of all profiles. Our single 19 year-old male driver found his Infinity quote to cost 50% more than Western General, and 39% higher than Mercury.

Infinity vs. standard auto insurer: Infinity is more affordable for higher-risk drivers – such as single 19-year-old drivers, than Nationwide, a standard auto insurance provider we have used for the purpose of comparison. While both married and single drivers aged 30 and above find Nationwide cheaper than Infinity, single 19 year-old drivers, who are considered higher-risk for their age and limited driving experience, will find Infinity much more affordable.

Infinity Auto Insurance Roadside Assistance Programs

Our Infinity Car Insurance Review

Our review of Infinity’s private passenger car insurance consists of highlights on both its policies and services that we thought consumers should know about (unique to us). Immediately below, you will find a map of Infinity’s national coverage. Its coverage states have changed since 2014, so check it out to see if it is still available in your state.

Infinity Coverage Map

Infinity focuses its private passenger auto business within 7 states. However, in its 2014 annual report, it declared that it will cease selling new auto insurance policies in three of these “focus states” – while maintaining renewal business there – and focus operation in the remaining four. For consumers living outside of any of these 4 focus states, entering your zip code into Infinity’s online quoting system will take you to Answer Financial, an auto insurance shopping agency, for other available insurers in your state.

Make sure to contact your local Armstrong Insurance agent in order to obtain a quote on Auto, Home or Commercial insurance policies anywhere in Florida.